According to News.com, PayPal is being charged with breaking the Patriot Act. The story doesn’t tell us exactly how they broke a law designed to hinder or stop terrorist attacks. Instead, it seems the problem comes from the fact that PayPal may have been used to process some online gambling payments.
Whether they processed gambling payments or not is immaterial to me. I want to know how processing online gambling payments supports terroristic acts against the U.S. Maybe that information hasn’t been made available yet, but this whole thing smacks of some overzealous law enforcement hiding behind their new-found powers. Indeed, what seems to have happened is that the ACLU’s and any other privacy advocate’s worst nightmare has come true. The government is using powers granted by laws enacted in overemotional reaction to a terror attack to attack issues and concerns that don’t serve the spirit of the law. Instead of monitoring the movements and online communications of known terrorist sympathizers, the government is instead cracking down on file sharing and online gambling.
These two “illegal” activities have nothing to do with terrorism or the Patriot Act, but the letter of that law allows the U.S. Attorney to force PayPal to turn over the payment records of all users over the past 6 months. Of course, I’m sure the U.S. Attorney won’t even think of over-looking any other suspicious payments as the search for the gambling payments slog through those records. The privacy of the individuals involved in those transactions will be egregiously endangered.
I suppose we should have known that it was only a matter of time before an incident like this cropped up. With all that power at their fingerprints, you know the government just couldn’t sit by and let that awful specter of sin like gambling go by unhampered.
Meanwhile, the federal government is attempting to force their will even further down the throats of the several Native American nations that have reservations in our country. They are insisting that they have the right to search the reservation governement’s records for some information regarding a crime, even though the reservations are sovereign nations. A few states have seen fit to create agreements from government to government to ensure that information can be shared equally, but other states simply want to force the hand of the reservation governments.
This feeling of all-encompassing power and invulnerability seems to extend down from the top. President Bush, with his war in Iraq, clearly believes that he can do whatever he wants. Furthermore, he believes that the consequences can be spun to his benefit, regardless of the outcome. This cavalier attitude for the precious rights we all hold dear is to be the downfall of Bush. I only wonder how many he’ll take with him. Tune to CNN to find out.


